MyCarTSB

2016 Subaru Forester Transmission Problems

43 owner-reported transmission complaints from NHTSA data

43
Complaints
5
Crashes
Feb 2021Dec 2022
Date Range

Data sourced from NHTSA public database. For informational purposes only. Always consult a qualified mechanic.

Owner Complaints (43)

criticalPOWER TRAIN,SERVICE BRAKES,ENGINE
CrashFiled: Oct 2024

When parked on a slope, driver attempted to back SUV out of parking space. Before starting car, with key inserted, ignition on and foot on brake, driver attempted to remove gearshift from park. Car drifted backward rapidly and uncontrollably.

NHTSA #: 11618333
criticalPOWER TRAIN
CrashFiled: Feb 2023

When accelerator is slightly pushed after the vehicle has come to stop it accelerates in a jack rabbit manner. The driver stopped at beginning of driveway parking area, and decided to move slightly forward. A slight push on accelerator pedal caused vehicle to lurch forward and do $8,700 damage to the closed 2 car garage door, and $1,000+ to vehicle.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11506839
criticalPOWER TRAIN,UNKNOWN OR OTHER,FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM
Filed: Aug 2020

Vehicle was traveling on highway around 70 MPH. Lost power to wheels/vehicle stalled with no warning. Engine revved to high RPM's when I hit gas, as I coasted into the grassy median.

NHTSA #: 11343912
criticalPOWER TRAIN
CrashFiled: Jul 2018

While pulling into a parking lot spot at idle speed, I lightly depressed the accelerator when all of a sudden the vehicle surged forward colliding with the veh parked to my left. My veh jumped the curb with the front end coming to rest on the sidewalk. I have had continuing problems with this sudden surging especially when pulling up a slight incline to enter my garage or starting from a stop.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11113183
criticalPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Apr 2018

Broken transmission due to broken transmission belt at 43,000 miles. I was stopped at a red light, when the light turned green I took my foot off the brake and put my foot on the accelerator. Immediately, there was a huge bang, and my car rocked back and forth.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11083794
criticalPOWER TRAIN,VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL,ELECTRONIC STABILITY CONTROL (ESC)
Filed: Feb 2017

I've had the same issue happen on 2 separate occasions (october and november 2016) - while driving the car I bought brand new, and going appx. 75 MPH down the interstate, driving approximately 2 hours straight on flat interstate, the RPM's all of a sudden shoot up and it feels like my car falls out of gear.

NHTSA #: 10957292
criticalPOWER TRAIN
CrashFiled: Sep 2016

Tl* the contact owns a 2016 subaru forester. While the vehicle was in reverse, it accelerated and crashed into a parked vehicle without warning. There were no injuries and a police report was not filed.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 10909317
highPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM,ENGINE
Filed: Oct 2023

While driving my vehicle on my daily trip to work, I experience sudden power loss. My interior lights began to blink erratically, as my vehicle loss power and caused me to panic, as I was entering the highway. Some highways have no shoulders, so as quickly as I entered the highway, I pulled off took the next exit.

NHTSA #: 11548758
highPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM,ENGINE
Filed: Nov 2022

Check engine light, service emissions, dash lights blinking and loss of power!!! I was pulling out into a busy intersection and warning lights started to flash and I lost power to cylinder #2 (per the technician at Van Subaru, he told me the alternator was sending bad info to the computer) and I was almost T-BONED as I limped through the intersection.

NHTSA #: 11494605
highPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM,ENGINE
Filed: Jul 2021

Car turns itself off soon after starting when you try and put it into gear. Even after a tune up the car just stalls out when starting or low idle while sitting at light

NHTSA #: 11424729
highPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Nov 2020

Transmission failure

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11372759
highPOWER TRAIN,ENGINE
Filed: Mar 2020

Around 75k miles, the "at temp" light began to appear when driving the car for more than 35-40 minutes on the highway at continuous speeds. No code was stored when it was brought to the dealership. I have pictures of this light being on numerous times.

NHTSA #: 11316297
highPOWER TRAIN,ENGINE
Filed: Jun 2019

On two different occasions 24 hours apart the car stalled (seemed to drop into neutral) at highway speeds ~80mph after greater than 1.5 hours of driving. The RPM jumped up and the car lost all acceleration despite pressing the accelerator. Once on the side of the road in park the engine died.

NHTSA #: 11218540
highPOWER TRAIN,ENGINE
Filed: Jun 2019

2 separate incidents of complete engine power loss while on highway at cruising speeds. First incident occurred while the vehicle was going about 70mph on a highway. We heard a loud bang then engine died and we lost all power to the car.

NHTSA #: 11217750
highPOWER TRAIN,VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL,ENGINE
Filed: Sep 2018

On five different occurrences while the cruise control was on and we were driving at around 70 miles an hour on an interstate, our car would electronically put itself in neutral, the automatic gear shifter would physically remain in drive, the RPM's would go up to about 5500 rpms, because the car was slowing down and the cruise control was on.

NHTSA #: 11129380
highPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Sep 2018

I drove from nj to me (bought in 2017). I noticed difficulty when trying to accelerate/pass cars from the left lane. I thought nothing of it.

NHTSA #: 11123966
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Aug 2025

THIS VEHICLE IS NOT SAFE TO DRIVE SINCE SUBARU COULD NOT REPLICATE THE ORIGINAL OVERHEATING PROBLEM IN THE TRANSMISSION. THEY MADE AN EDUCATED GUESS REPAIR TO SEE IF IT FIXES THE OVERHEATING PROBLEMS IN THE TRANSMISSION WHICH MAY MALFUNCTION DURING DRIVING THE VEHICLE,SLIPPAGE, TO LOCKINGUP.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11680675
mediumPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Aug 2024

113,727 miles. 2016 Subaru Forester. 5 different warning lights all came on at the same time.

NHTSA #: 11606047
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Jul 2024

Subaru is aware of issues with their transmission system and previously offered an extension but my car is outside the 100k limit. The transmission started to fail and each time I stopped at an intersection, it would start to idle roughly and try and lurch foreward even with the brake fully depressed.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11597922
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Dec 2022

The contact owns 2016 Subaru Forester. The contact stated while attempting to drive from a complete stop, the accelerator pedal was depressed but the vehicle hesitated to respond. The contact stated that she persistently depressed the accelerator pedal until the vehicle responded.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11497340
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Oct 2022

The contact owns a 2016 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that after starting the vehicle, various warning lights were illuminated. After using a personal diagnostic reader, he retrieved two unknown failure codes.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11489198
mediumPOWER TRAIN
CrashFiled: Aug 2022

Pulled into parking space in shopping mall. The car accelerated over the curb and ran into a store front knocking out a wall. The car was still in Drive when it came to a stop.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11480037
mediumPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Jun 2022

The contact owns a 2016 Subaru Forester. The contact stated while driving at various speeds, the vehicle started jerking and hesitating while attempting to accelerate. The vehicle was taken to the local dealer and the transmission fluid was flushed; however, after retrieving the vehicle the failure persisted.

NHTSA #: 11471298
mediumPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Sep 2020

Tl* the contact owns a 2016 subaru forester. The contact stated that the key was stuck in the ignition. The contact stated that several attempts were made before the key released and was removed from the ignition.

NHTSA #: 11361857
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Jul 2020

There is a leak in the head gasket which ruined a temperature gauge ($700 to replace). The mechanics say it is a design flaw and there is nothing I could do to avoid the issue and it will keep happening until I fix the leak.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11339614
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Jul 2020

Tl* the contact owns a 2016 subaru forester. The contact stated that the vehicle was taken to camelback subaru located at 1521 e camelback rd, phoenix, az 85014, (602) 680-2495 for the 120,000 miles vehicle inspection. The contact stated that after picking up the vehicle and driving at an undisclosed, the transmission overheat warning light illuminated.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11338218
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Jun 2020

The key has started getting stuck in the ignition intermittently after turning the motor off. Sometimes it takes several attempts involving turning the motor back on and pulling the key out as I'm turning the motor off. It may go a couple of days and be fine then do it several times in a row.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11326779
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Oct 2019

CVT codes p0700 and p2764 came on. The dealership said that it needs a whole new transmission as fixing just the torque converter will not fix the issue. All warning lights came on and none of the safety features will work.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11265402
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Aug 2019

My car is slowing down drastically while my foot is on the gas and RPM is increasing. I suspect that the CVT is slipping and causing the car to engine brake. This is the reason subaru extended the CVT warranty, but they have refused to replace my transmission because the dealer has not been able to duplicate the problem.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11246210
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Apr 2019

Tl* the contact owns a 2016 subaru forester. The contact stated that the vehicle shifted out of park after the engine was turned off. The failure occurred every time the contact parked the vehicle and removed the key from the ignition.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11202977
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Sep 2018

Safety concern regarding manual transmission coming out of gear while engine braking.this has happened on flat roads and while descending hills, and while in first or seconds gear. Issue easily duplicated when in first gear at low speed (between 1,500 and 3,000 RPM) going downhill with foot off gas pedal.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11129115
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Feb 2018

Tl* the contact owns a 2016 subaru forester. While driving various speeds, the vehicle hesitated to accelerate. Klamath falls subaru in klamath falls, oregon 97603 was made aware of the failure but the failure was not diagnosed or repaired.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11073912
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Nov 2016

When shifting from reverse to drive, there is a 3 to 4 second lag time in the transmission between shifting and getting power to the wheels. This is very dangerous when you back out of your driveway, especially if you live on a busy street (as we do). I took it to the dealer today and they said this is normal for the type of transmission (CVT) and they wouldn't even look at it.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 10928684
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Sep 2016

When you go from reverse to drive there is a lag time in the transmission. Or if you go from park to drive its the same. This is very dangerous as you rely on your car moving when you shift from reverse to drive (e.g., when you back out of your driveway).

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 10904762
mediumPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Aug 2016

When you go from reverse to drive there is a lag time in the transmission. Or if you go from park to drive its the same. If your on an incline it makes you hit the gas to accelerate.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 10896771
lowPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Aug 2025

I bought the car between 82-90K miles. Not long after I noticed when I was at an intersection and went from a stopped position to accelerating it would barely go. Spent over a lot to fix it and the guy who did says he has 2-3 Forresters a month in his shop for the same issue.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11683894
lowPOWER TRAIN,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM,ENGINE
Filed: Jul 2021

Key stuck in switch when car is put into park. Steering locks up and then can not restart or remove key. This happens almost daily at this point

NHTSA #: 11424727
lowPOWER TRAIN,UNKNOWN OR OTHER,SERVICE BRAKES
Filed: Feb 2021

Key stuck in ignition when car is in park.

NHTSA #: 11394412
lowPOWER TRAIN,SERVICE BRAKES,ENGINE
Filed: Oct 2020

When stopping/stopped it will suddenly accelerate/surge forward and I need to slam on brakes

NHTSA #: 11364886
lowPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Oct 2020

When vehicle is placed in park after a trip, the key becomes stuck in the ignition. The vehicle is able to be turned off but the key is unable to be removed from the ignition. Cycling the key in the ignition and placing the car back in park multiple times allows the key to eventually be removed from the ignition.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11362183
lowPOWER TRAIN,UNKNOWN OR OTHER
Filed: Sep 2020

2016 subaru forester. Key gets stuck in ignition. Can not be removed.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11354067
lowPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Mar 2017

When making a right or left turn the vehicle will bog down and it will not move. The situation last about 5 seconds and during this time I am unable to get out of the way of oncoming traffic. The happens multiple times per day to none per day.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 10966681
lowPOWER TRAIN
Filed: Nov 2016

Vehicle was parked on a level surface. I started the car, put my foot on the brake. Release the parking brake, put the car into drive, release the brake.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 10926830

Other 2016 Subaru Forester Issues